QUICK LINKS
Lower East Side Rezoning
On November 6th, 2006, the Department of City Planning presented its plan to guide future development of the Lower East side in anticipation of the area's first rezoning since 1961. After more discussion with the community and completion of the draft Environmental Review Statement, DCP hopes to push a finalized plan through the city's land use review process, ULURP, this year. The vast majority of the area, encompassing more than 100 city blocks, would be rezoned with a height cap of 80 feet. The zoning would also end a height exemption available for most community facilities, like dorms or hospitals, and would require new developments to build flush to the street line, preventing "tower-in-park" buildings that soar high above the low-rise neighborhoods. However, areas along East Houston, Delancey, and Christie Streets, and stretches of Second Avenue and Avenue D will be rezoned to allow buildings up to 12 stories high, if developers agree to set aside 20 percent of their projects as affordable housing in accordance with the city’s expanding Inclusionary Housing Program.
Opponents of the plan fear that increased development will transform the neighborhood's character, increasing traffic, displacing longtime residents and unleashing scores of rats. They further fear that existing, lower-rise buildings will be razed to make way for new developments built up to the height limit. Residents also argue that the plan doesn't provide enough affordable housing. On the other hand, developers also oppose the existing plan as too restrictive of development. Proponents of the plan say it strikes a good balance between preserving the area's existing character with more restrictive zoning and creating corridors for increased housing density and incentives for affordable housing.
Presently the Department of City Planning is preparing a draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS) as the first phase of the environmental review process showing the impacts of development on the neighborhood. On June 25, 2007, DCP held a public meeting to discuss and get input on the Draft Environmental Impact Statement (DEIS), the first phase of the environmental review process showing the impacts of development on the neighborhood. The meeting discussed what will be addressed in the DEIS, how it be implemented and what can be done to solve potential site issues. Public commentary will be incorporated as the DCP moves forward in the process. Once the DEIS is complete the project can move into ULURP; this is scheduled to take place in the spring of 2008.
Borough President Receives Petition Against LES Rezoning
Wednesday, July 16, 2008 | Metro New York | Topic: Land Use
Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer received a petition of 10,000 signatures against the proposed Lower East Side rezoning. The petition was presented by the Coalition of Chinatown and Lowest East Side Residents. The group is concerned that the rezoning is not “inclusive” and will encourage development in minority neighborhoods.
Community Groups Protest Lower Eastside Rezoning Plan
Wednesday, July 16, 2008 | New York Times | Topic: Land Use
The Coalition to Protect Chinatown and the Lower East Side protested the City's rezoning plan yesterday after submitting a petition against the plan, which some feel is exclusionary, to the Manhattan Borough President's office. The rezoning plan has already passed Community Board 3 and Scott Stringer, the Manhattan Borough President must make a decision by August 11. Community groups are calling for a more comprehensive rezoning involving a larger portion of the neighborhood and to have more affordable housing components incorporated.
Burden: East Side Rezoning Designed to Prevent “Out-of-Scale Dorms”
Monday, June 09, 2008 | New York Post | Topic: Land Use
The rezoning plan proposed by the Department of City Planning is designed to protect two neighborhoods under threat of overdevelopment, the Lower East Side and the East Village, according to City Planning Commissioner Amanda Burden. Of particular concern to some preservationists is the threat of high-rise dormitories, especially as NYU has announced its need for an additional 6 million square feet to accommodate growth. President of the Greenwich Village Society for Historic Preservation, Andrew Berman says that while the rezoning should successfully protect the areas from high-rise development, the rezoned area should have been larger. The rezoning plan is currently undergoing community review.
Chinatown Residents Claim City's Rezoning Plan is Discriminatory; More Affordable Housing Requested
Wednesday, May 14, 2008 | The Villager | Topic:
At a rowdy public hearing on the city's plan to rezone parts of the Lower East Side and East Village, some residents of Chinatown claimed that the plans were discriminatory because areas of LES were left out of the plan. Another concern is affordable housing. The community has asked for 30% inclusionary zoning while the proposal only has 20% currently.
LES Rezoning Draws Protest
Tuesday, May 13, 2008 | NY1 | Topic: Land Use
Opponents of the City's plan to rezone parts of the Lower East Side protested both inside and outside a Community Board hearing on the plans on Monday. The plan will rezone 111 blocks and place building height limitations on new structures. Some believe that the height limitations exclude new developments in predominantly poor and minority neighborhoods and claim that the City is trying to push out minorities and lower-income residents. Some opponents claim that the City left them out of the rezoning process until it was too late to make any changes. The City denies these claims. If the plan goes through, the LES rezoning could be the third largest rezoning the City has undertaken.
Lower East Side Rezoning Proposal Goes to Community Board
Monday, May 12, 2008 | WNYC | Topic: Land Use
In order to restrict out of scale development in the Lower East Side neighborhood, the City is proposing a rezoning to limit height to 8 stories throughout the majority of the area. As of now no restrictions are in place and developers are able to buy adjacent building lots' air rights allowing for larger scale development. The rezoning has reached the community board and if passed will go on to the borough president's office.
Public Review Process to Start for LES and East Village Rezoning
Tuesday, May 06, 2008 | New York Sun | Topic: Land Use
The Uniform Land Use Review Procedure (ULURP) will begin for plans to rezone 110 blocks in the Lower East Side and the East Village. The rezoning, bounded by E. 13th Street, Avenue D, Grand and Delancey Streets, and Third Avenue and the Bowery, will lower height limits, require all building to line up to the street, and provide incentives for affordable housing and other residential projects. City Planning Commissioner Amanda Burden said that such a rezoning “respects and preserves these vitally important neighborhoods.” Community Board 3 has 60 days to review the rezoning.
Chinatown Residents Protest “Unfair” LES Rezoning
Wednesday, April 09, 2008 | The Villager | Topic: Land Use
Residents of Chinatown spoke up at a recent Community Board 3 meeting about what they see as an unfair plan to rezone 114 blocks in the East Village, the Lower East Side and a small part of Chinatown to limit high rise development. Residents, many of whom spoke through a Chinese translator, called the plan “racist” saying that by not including Chinatown in the down-zoning, it would push high rise luxury development into their neighborhood, making it unaffordable to them. They complained that they had not been included in the planning process and that the rezoning had been planned “away from public scrutiny.” CB 3 members responded by urging residents to get more involved in the planning process.
Protest Over Cooper Square Hotel and Rezoning the Bowery
Sunday, December 16, 2007 | New York Times | Topic: Land Use
Community members are protesting the construction of the Cooper Square Hotel and new developments along the Bowery. Recently, bars and restaurants serving a late night crowd have located along Bowery which many believe is disrupting the quality of the neighborhood. On a bigger scale, however, some are concerned that the Bowery was not included in proposals to rezone 114 blocks in the East Village and Lower East Side to protect the low-rise character of the neighborhood. The City Planning Commission has said that since Bowery is a large street, a different approach must be used to protect its character than what is being used on smaller, narrower streets.
Lower East Site Residents Seek Development
Monday, November 05, 2007 | Metro New York | Topic: Land Use
At a rally on Sunday, members of the Seward Park Area Renewal Coalition urged the city to build a mix of low and middle income housing along with cultural amenities on the vacant lots that make up the area known as the Steward Park Urban Renewal Project. The site, roughly 5 acres, was cleared of residents roughly 40 years ago to make way for affordable housing. Yet, today most of the lots remain vacant aside from parked cars. Neighborhood residents are mixed in what they think should be built on the site. The city last tried to develop a plan for the area in 2003.
Final Scope of Work Expected for Lower East Side Rezoning
Wednesday, October 24, 2007 | The Villager | Topic: Land Use
After the public scoping meeting in June the city continues to review comments from the community before releasing its final scope of work. Community Board 3, local business owners, and members of the business improvement district (BID) all submitted comments for consideration of the existing plan. The community board is advocating increases in affordable housing while local businesses focus on growth restraints of zoning as well as building restrictions associated with possible landmark status. The ULURP process will begin once the results are compiled.
LES/East Village Rezoning Proposal To Be Presented
Friday, June 22, 2007 | The Villager | Topic: Urban Design & Architecture
The Department of City Planning will be presenting its proposal for the Lower East Side and East Village rezoning on Monday, June 25th. Residents will be given 10 days after the meeting to submit any public comment on the proposal. The rezoning calls for allowing taller buildings on East Houston and other wide streets, and allows for additional height based on the inclusion of affordable housing. On other narrower streets building heights will be capped at lower levels than what is required under current zoning laws.
The EDC Looks for New Uses of Essex Street Market
Monday, June 04, 2007 | Metro New York | Topic: Land Use
The Economic Development Corporation is considering potential uses for the current Essex Street Market, including identifying a food retailer and possibly office space or light manufacturing. The director of the Lower East Side Business Improvement District believes that the area could be a center of creative activity, and one where business can take advantage of special state tax incentives as they are part of an Empire Zone. Some in the community are worried, however, that one of the buildings at the site may be turned into luxury apartments, although that has not yet been proposed by the EDC.
Lower East Side Becomes New Location for Luxury Residential
Thursday, May 17, 2007 | New York Sun | Topic: Housing
The Lower East Side has recently seen incredibly rent increases as luxury developments continue to be completed. With rents continuing to increase in other desired neighborhoods, renters have been moving east out of Greenwich Village, Chelsea, or Soho into the LES, drawn by the varied nightlife scene, new restaurants and stores. Given the shortage of land within Manhattan, real estate insiders find it no surprise that that neighborhood is quickly changing as developers seize on to any development opportunities. Existing residents are concerned about gentrification and the impact on the neighborhood's culture.
Many New Rental Apartments Being Built
Thursday, November 30, 2006 | New York Sun | Topic: Housing
Manhattan’s incredibly low vacancy rate for rental apartments has triggered a number of developers to focus on construction of residential rental apartments. New rental buildings are planned or already under construction in West Chelsea, the Lower East Side, and Long Island City.
City and Lower East Side Residents Debate Building Heights
Wednesday, November 08, 2006 | AM New York | Topic: Land Use
On Monday, November 6 the Department of Planning and Lower East Residents quarreled over details of the City’s rezoning proposal for the Lower East Side. While the City maintains that 80 feet is an appropriate cap to building height, some local citizens believe that a 60-foot maximum is more consistent with the neighborhood aesthetic. The height restriction will not go into effect for another year, however, creating concern among some residents that high-rise developments will continue in the meantime.
Community Board 3 Hears Preliminary Plans: NYU-Area Residents React
Tuesday, November 07, 2006 | Washington Square News | Topic: Land Use
At Community Board 3’s November 6 meeting some East Village and Lower East Side residents reacted harshly to the Department of City Planning's introduction of re-zoning plans for the area. While the goals of the Department of City Planning were to mandate size restrictions and inquire about areas for low-cost housing, many in the crowd objected to the plans’ exclusion of Third Avenue and blocks to the west. Many area residents fear that NYU’s planned 26-story residence hall would escape community input, as a result of this exclusion.
Lower East Side Rezoning Proposed
Wednesday, November 01, 2006 | The Villager | Topic: Land Use
The Lower East Side’s Community Board 3 recently heard from the Department of City Planning concerning a proposed rezoning plan. The area under consideration includes more than 100 blocks bounded by 13th Street, Avenue D, Houston Street and Broadway. While there are concerns among residents about zoning changes, City officials say the proposal is in response to the extensive development that is already occurring in the area.


